This article originally appeared on Entertainment Weekly. For more stories like this, visit

By EW.COM/Nick Romano
Updated Sep 19, 2017 @ 11:15 am
Credit: Michael Rozman/Warner Bros

Ellen DeGeneres felt she had to up her pranking game for guest Sarah Paulson, which meant bad things for the star of American Horror Story: Cult.

First, DeGeneres spooked Paulson by hiding in her dressing room’s closet and emerging with a creepy sideshow laugh. As they were discussing the scare on stage, the host had one of her assistants sneak up behind Paulson wearing a wig, cape, fedora, and striped socks. But the comedienne was disappointed they didn’t get a good face shot for the cameras.

“What are you gonna do now?” Paulson asked on edge. DeGeneres promised “nothing,” but the actress had a feeling something was about to pop out of the chest by their table. As soon as she mentioned, “That has happened,” a guy dressed as a clown shrieked out of the box and ran off stage.

And there’s the face shot!

Watch all three scares in the clip above.

This Story Originally Appeared On Entertainment Weekly