The Vampire Diaries
Credit: The CW

We spotted Nina Dobrev at the Hervé Léger runway show at at New York Fashion Week, and we couldn't help but wonder how she'd vote in our Valentine's Day Vampire Diaries "Take It or Stake It" poll! When asked which of her co-stars' hearts she would "take" and which one she would "stake," she totally surprised us! "I would stake Klaus (Joseph Morgan)," she began. "But as Elena, I would take Matt (Zach Roerig) because he was in love with her and she loved him." Zing! Take that, Salvatore boys! Now it's your turn: Which of Mystic Falls' many male vampires owns your beating heart? Click "Take the Poll" below to cast your vote! We'll announce the biggest heart-stealer on Valentine's Day tomorrow.

— Reporting by Lauren Tumas