The Vampire Diaries
Credit: Courtesy of The CW

Elena (Nina Dobrev) chose Stefan (Paul Wesley) over his brother Damon (real-life love Ian Somerhalder) on the third season finale of The Vampire Diaries, but will the decision stick? "When she gets tired of Stefan, who knows? Maybe she'll come to Damon?" Somerhalder told E! at Comic-Con. "Seasons two and three, he did everything they wanted him to do. He tried to be the person they wanted him to be. Guess what? None of it worked." It sounds like bad boy Damon is back! We'll have the wait until The Vampire Diaries' returns on October 11th to find out what happens, but in the meantime, we're curious—who would you choose? Vote in the poll and let us know!