By Aly Semigran
Updated Feb 19, 2015 @ 10:12 am
Hugh Grant SJP Plead the Fifth WWHL
Credit: Courtesy

If you've been wishing and hoping that Hugh Grant and Sarah Jessica Parker would work together again, then you're in luck. Well, kind of. Grant appeared on Watch What Happens Live on Wednesday night when his Did You Hear About the Morgans? co-star SJP called in to ask one of the questions during host Andy Cohen's infamous WWHL segment Plead the Fifth.

After willingly answering the first two Plead the Fifth questions, including Cohen's query about why his relationship with Elizabeth Hurley didn't work out (to which Grant sweetly and sincerely responded, "The funny thing is, it did. She's still my best friend...number one person I call when I'm in a crisis"), Parker stumped The Rewrite star over the phone. When the Sex and the City star asked which actress he'd never work with again, Grant opted to plead the fifth and joked, "The list would have been too long."

Of course, Parker wouldn't be on that list, as the two stars both praised each other as one of their favorites. All right, these two really do need to work together again!

Watch Hugh Grant's Plead the Fifth Segment on Watch What Happens Live by clicking on the video below.