By Aly Semigran
Updated Jan 16, 2015 @ 9:44 am
Credit: Courtesy

Watch What Happens Live! host Andy Cohen picked a good week to get Gwyneth Paltrow to play Plead the Fifth, as the Oscar-winning actress hasn't been holding back. After a candid interview with Howard Stern (in which she opened up about everything from her "conscious uncoupling" and her ex Brad Pitt being "too good" for her), the Mortdecai star visited WWHL and agreed to play the gossip-worthy game.

As luck would have it, Paltrow was still in a sharing mood, and didn't plead the fifth once during Cohen's tough line of questioning. Paltrow— who wore a lovely Safiyaa jumpsuit for her appearance— talked about an infamous Goop post, as well as which of her exes current partners she'd rather be stuck in an elevator with: Angelina Jolie or Jennifer Garner.

"I think either," Paltrow said, adding, "I really like Jennifer Garner. I don't know Angelina Jolie very well." Cohen insisted that during their time in an elevator together they could get to know each other, to which Paltrow happily obliged, "Let's say Angelina Jolie, then."

Watch Paltrow play Plead the Fifth here:

Paltrow also played along for Cohen's "I'm So Goopy," in which she answered questions about her lowbrow indulgences. It turns out that the star likes Taco Bell, sweatpants, and Sex and the City marathons, but not reality TV or gossip magazines: