Anna Camp and Skylar Astin’s love story has looked picture perfect (see what I did there?) but the Pitch Perfect 3 star says one thing was a little off when her now-husband proposed: her outfit.

Camp stopped by Dirty Laundry with InStyle Editor-in-Chief Laura Brown and dished on the “not fancy at all” ensemble she was wearing when Astin popped the question: A graphic tee that used to be his. “I got engaged wearing this shirt,” she tells Brown in the video at top, showing it off.

Anna Camp Dirty Laundry - Tout
Credit: Time Inc. Digital Studio

“Were you wearing only that shirt?” Brown asks. “I wish! No, it’s not that sexy of a story,” the actress explains. “We were in Hawaii and I didn’t know I was going to get proposed to. And he said, ‘Let’s just get up in the morning and go get coffee.’ And so I said, ‘Well should I change? You know, I’m wearing this like ratty T-shirt that you gave me.’ And he said, ‘No, I love you in this shirt.’” Aww.

“He ends up taking me to the top of a hill and in Kauai looking over the ocean and asked me to marry him while I’m wearing this,” she said.

Watch the swoon-worthy video above and catch the full episode on People TV.