We've never been ones to judge a book by its cover, but if the cover happens to be particularly adorable, it becomes all the more enticing. The same holds true for our beauty stash---we're suckers for some pretty packaging, but if the cutest cat-shaped nail polish in the world doesn't live up to our expectations, don't expect it to go into heavy rotation. On the hunt to fulfill equal parts kitsch and quality, we rounded up 12 of our favorite cute beauty products that are more than just a pretty face. These high performance formulas, pigmented colors, and indulgent scents are just as gorgeous on your vanity as they are on you, and to boot, make an unexpected Valentine's Gift your BFF or the tween in your life is sure to love. Click through our gallery to see each one now!