These Wines Will Pair Perfectly with Your Easter Candy

First up on our list is the Jennifer Aniston of the Easter basket: the chocolate bunny. Beautiful and forever a crowd-pleaser, the chocolate bunny is the star of everyone's sugar haul.

"Chocolate is a little easier to pair because if you have a deep red wine you love and a rich delicious chocolate you love, you're gold," explains O’Connell. "My personal penchant is to take a big red with some sweetness. I turned to a ripasso style Italian wine called Appassimento which is extra ripe and almost raisin-y delicious because the winemaker sun-dried the grapes to make them more concentrated and extremely flavored. It's rich and goes well with chocolate." Whatever red wine you pick, O'Connell suggests you go big or go home: "The darker and richer, the better."

Candy: Godiva Chocolate Bunny and Eggs, $30; amazon.com

Wine: Christian Patat Appassimento 2014, $19; nakedwines.com

"Sherry-styled wines are a classic pairing for peanut butter," says O'Connell of the sweet-and-salty snacking standby. For the richness of Reese's chocolate-and-peanut-butter confection, try pairing a sweet wine that will compliment both the nuttiness and sugariness. "A nice sip of a ROX Late Harvest has a refreshing nutty quality (and still some sweetness to pair with the candy) that gets you aching for another bite." Consider yourself warned—a major binge session is eminent! 

Candy: Reese's Peanut Butter Eggs, $11 for 6; amazon.com

Wine: Scott Peterson's ROX Late Harvest Sauvignon Blanc 2013, $30; nakedwines.com

To stand up to the fruity nature of jelly beans, O'Connell prescribes a sleek white wine: "Jelly beans are juicy and sweet so we would recommend to pair them with an icy, super-crisp pinot grigio." 

Candy: Superfruit Jelly Beans, $40 for 2.5 lbs; sugarfina.com

Wine: Stephen Millier Angel's Reserve Pinot Grigio Lodi 2015, $16; nakedwines.com

Peeps are probably the most go-for-broke, unapologetically sugary treat on our list. So what exactly do you pair with an ooey-gooey marshmallow rolled in neon sugar? O'Connell says it's time to get sparkling. "Peeps are undeniably sweet and fluffy so I'd pour a wine that is also sweet and not too structured. I love prosecco-style wines for this: sparkling with a touch of sweetness that doesn't take itself too seriously."

Candy: Original Peeps, $13 for 20; amazon.com

Wine: Keith Hock Bollicine in Bianco, $22; nakedwines.com 

This spring treat turned out to be the trickiest to pair with a wine on our list. Fear not: the Naked Wines team kept taste testing until they had the perfect pour to recommend. (Our heroes!)

"The Cadbury Creme Egg is so sweet and rich that it was hard to pair with another sweet wine," explains O'Connell. "Instead, we went with a bone-dry Beaujolais called 'La Rose Pourpre.' The deep purple wine is rich and lush and dripping with red fruit like strawberry and raspberry. In this pairing, the wine is almost like a hearty food, the foundation of the meal—and the egg is just a little treat that you take a creamy caramel sip from.​ . . [It turned out to be] the weirdest pairing we tried—and a wild success! "

Candy: Cadbury Creme Egg, $13 for 12; amazon.com

Wine: Mickael Lachaud’s Beaujolais VV La Rose Pourpre 2014​, $20; nakedwines.com 

Love 'em or hate 'em, Peeps continue to multiply in flavors, shapes, and varieties season by season. "Flavored peeps are tough [to pair] because the flavors are so big and artificial. We recommend a big wine with some sweetness and some less artificial, more natural fruit flavors to pair," says O'Connell. For example, match blue raspberry Peeps with a Ruby Port. "The blue raspberry has this sweet, fake berry flavor and the ruby port has an intensely deep real berry flavor so they go great together."

Candy: Raspberry Peeps, $5 for 10; amazon.com

Wine: Montaria Ruby Port Reserva, $24; nakedwines.com

If your candy profile is partial to malted milk flavors, you'll want to pair up Robin Eggs with a "big intense petite sirah that plows over the malt ball flavor and rounds out that rich milk-chocolate feeling," says O'Connell.

Bonus: pairing the Whoopers-style candy with sirah can envoke movie-theater memories. "Stephen Millier's petite sirah almost tastes like cherry cola so it's a classic movie theater pairing—malt balls and Cherry Coke—except now it has wine in it!" Win-win.

Candy: Robin Eggs, $8 for 13.75 oz.; amazon.com 

Wine: F. Stephen Millier Black Label Reserve Petite Sirah Calaveras County 2014, $18; nakedwines.com