Chunky Loafers Are Back—Here Are the Pairs You Need to Shop

It’s the ‘90s all over again.

We independently research, test, review, and recommend the best products—learn more about our process. If you buy something through our links, we may earn a commission.

Chunky loafer roundup
Streetstyleshooters/Getty

Aside from a pair of stretchy black slip-ons and maybe some thickly-soled Skechers, chunky loafers were in every '90s girl's shoe rotation. While the thought of introducing a pair into your adult wardrobe may have once made you cringe, these bad boys are back with stamps of approval from celebs like Bella Hadid, Katie Holmes, and Alexa Chung. And, honestly? There's no better time for them.

So if you're suddenly craving a dose of '90s-inspired fashion (yeah, us too), we've pulled together several chunky loafers that are perfect for working into any outfit. We chose the styles with the best materials, colors, design, and comfort level.

These are the best chunky loafers:

  • Dr. Martens 1461 Quad Platform Derby at Nordstrom
  • Sam Edelman Tully Platform Loafer at Nordstrom
  • Dirty Laundry Women's Heeled Loafer at Amazon
  • Franco Sarto Carolynn Tassel Loafer at Nordstrom
  • Vionic Cheryl Loafer at Amazon

Our Top Picks

Dr. Martens 1461 Quad Platform Derby

Dr. Martens 1461 Quad Platform Derby
Courtesy

What We Love: The shoes are built to last.
What We Don't Love: They are a bit heavy.

Though it was founded in the 1940s, Dr. Martens' chunky shoes were synonymous with the grunge era. So if it's a no-fail classic you're after, these derby platform shoes deserve a spot in your closet. The sky-high platform sole amps up the drama, but the black and white color options ensure the shoe can go with any outfit. Dr. Martens' real leather designs are known for their high quality craftsmanship, so it's no surprise that celebrities from Gigi Hadid to Miley Cyrus are fans of the brand.

Heel: 2.25 inches | Colors: 2 | Material: Leather

Sam Edelman Tully Platform Loafer

sam edelman tully platform loafer
Courtesy

What We Love: They're a classic style you can wear with both casual and professional outfits.
What We Don't Love: You have to break them in.

Everyone should own a pair of leather shoes they can rely on through the fall and winter season. If you've yet to find your trusty staples, I'd like you to meet Sam Edelman's Tully loafers. Pair them with a sleek pantsuit, pop them on with your favorite jeans, or layer them with a sweater and dress and you've instantly polished your outfit. It helps that they fit well, too.

Heel: 1.5 inches | Colors: 3 | Material: Leather

Dirty Laundry Womens Heeled Loafer

Platform Loafer
Courtesy

What We Love: They are an edgy alternative to high heels.
What We Don't Love: Some may feel like they are too costumey for everyday.

I'm not in charge of a haunted Victorian mansion either, but if I were aiming to emulate the one and only Morticia Addams, my search for a pair of shoes would end here. Outside of fall activities, these lug-sole loafers are quite a fun and preppy heel with a nice bit of additional height. If you've been wanting to try the goth business casual trend, swap these heeled loafers for heels to add some vamp to your outfit.

Heel: 2.5 inches | Colors: 2 | Material: Synthetic

Franco Sarto Carolynn Tassel Loafer

FRANCO SARTO Carolynn Tassel Loafer
Courtesy

What We Love: Tassels and unconventional colors make these loafers stand out.
What We Don't Love: They run small.

As you already know, shoes can make or break an outfit — but they can also be the missing piece that takes a look from plain to smartly pulled together. The luster in the faux patent leather and tassels make these an instant statement piece that would satisfy minimalists, too. And that 1.5-inch platform makes them ideal for clomping around all season. If black isn't quite it for you, they're available in burgundy and navy for catering to your own style.

Heel: 1.5 inches | Colors: 3 | Material: Synthetic

Vionic Cheryl Loafer

Platform Loafer
Courtesy

What We Love: They're perfect for lounging around the house in style.
What We Don't Love: The soft leather and shearling can get dirty easily.

Sipping tea and roaming around with crunchy leaves underfoot won't be the same without this cozy pair that doesn't falter in style. They've still got the chunky sole, but the faux shearling detail softens them a bit more than their patent leather counterparts. Plus, the insole contains a three-part insert that makes wearing them feel just as comfy as they look. That forest getaway is calling your name.

Heel: 1.3 inches | Colors: 11 | Materials: Nubuck Leather with Shearling Upper

Your Questions, Answered

How do I style chunky loafers?

The original quintessential chunky loafer emanated quite a few different vibes: goth, preppy, punk, you name it. The same can still be said, but in this era, anything goes when it comes to sporting heeled loafers.

If you're going the route a la Bella Hadid, you'll want a pair of particularly thick loafers, which she has made the case for pairing with both a cardigan and bike shorts as well as wild early-2000s prints.

You can also tone down the chunky silhouette like Katie Holmes does and opt for a sleeker shoe that still provides plenty of style and sophistication. (Though even she tried out a pair of super chunky soles earlier this year).

And, surprisingly, less edgy looks can be completed with the right pair of leather loafers, whether you're a cottagecore fan or researching some cozy cabin looks —just try a creamy suede or white shearling chunky shoe.

Updated by
Emily Cieslak
Emily Cieslak, Assistant Commerce Editor
Emily Cieslak joined the Dotdash Meredith team in 2020, and more recently joined the InStyle team in 2022 as an Assistant Commerce Editor. She has worked in many sides of the fashion industry, empowering her to tackle fashion topics from an insider's angle. As an Assistant Commerce Editor, Emily combines her knowledge of retail and styling expertise when covering new trends and offering readers advice on how to shop for and style themselves. Her work has been published in Byrdie, Real Simple, The Knot, and Brides. Emily has a bachelor's degree in English from the University of Pennsylvania.
Was this page helpful?
Related Articles