Celebrity Carson Daly Got Jennifer Love Hewitt's Name Tattooed on His Leg And, subsequently, had it covered up … for Tara Reid. By Isabel Jones Isabel Jones Instagram Twitter Isabel is an Oregon-born and Brooklyn-based writer and editor with a special interest in pop culture. InStyle's editorial guidelines Updated on September 12, 2022 @ 05:22PM Pin Share Tweet Email Carson Daly, Jennifer Love Hewitt. Photo: Ron Galella, Ltd./Ron Galella Collection via Getty Images Who: TV host and former MTV VJ Carson Daly (DOB: June 22, 1973) and Golden Globe-nominated actress Jennifer Love Hewitt (DOB: February 21, 1979) How They Met: According to a Rolling Stone interview Love Hewitt gave in 1999, she and Daly met "for literally two seconds" at the storied MTV beach house. Their paths crossed a few more times in the tanned teen bubble that is the MTV VJ-verse and they began dating in 1998. "I think we deserve a huge round of applause," the I Know What You Did Last Summer alum told the magazine. "I think we've done a really good job — it's been almost a year now." When They Peaked: What is more evocative of the year 1998 than this image? Daly and Love Hewitt are a late '90s time capsule from head to toe — from his tiny earring to the hem of her ruffled chiffon midi dress. Steve Granitz Archive 1/WireImage Why We Loved Them: We're more impressed by how Daly and Love Hewitt conducted themselves in the aftermath of their relationship than during it. TBT: Jake Gyllenhaal Once Reportedly Spent $165,000 on a Date with Taylor Swift In 2003, Love Hewitt roasted her ex during MTV Bash: Carson Daly. After lampooning the former TRL host for everything from his taste in women (some not-so-subtle jabs were made at Daly's ex Tara Reid, in particular) to the, uh, volume of women he's spent time with, the Ghost Whisperer star ended her monologue on a sincere note: "Having you in my life was very important to me and being your girlfriend was truly one of the best things I've ever had the honor to do." Similarly, Daly bragged about dating Love Hewitt while riffing with Ryan Seacrest in 2006. "I forgot you dated her," Seacrest told his New Year's Eve special rival. "She has the clearest skin." Jeff Kravitz/FilmMagic The Breakup: While it's unclear exactly what happened between the pair, Daly had some qualms about the how of it all. Daly reportedly told People that he learned about his breakup not from Love Hewitt but from Howard Stern. TBT: Stevie Nicks Said the "Electric Crazy Attraction" Between Her and Lindsey Buckingham Will Never Die "I woke up to Howard Stern telling me my relationship with [Jennifer] was over," he said. "Then I heard Steve Kmetko on E! say, 'Just off the Associated Press: Jennifer Love Hewitt and Carson Daly have officially broken up." Daly maintained that he told his ex how he felt about the only-in-Hollywood scenario. "If we were going to break up officially like this, maybe we could have just talked about it," he remembered telling her. "I don't see why you had to tell your publicist. And now I have been publicly humiliated." Public humiliation notwithstanding, the exes hashed things out during an adorably awkward episode of Daly's talk show, Last Call with Carson Daly, in 2005. Jeffrey Mayer/WireImage Daly opened up about getting a tattoo of the actress's name on his leg and then having it covered up (allegedly at Reid's behest) with a crab claw pocket knife (yes, it's what it sounds like). Later, the host told his guest, "I blame the breakup on you, you blame it on me." TBT: Helena Bonham Carter Said Tim Burton Decorated His Christmas Tree With "Dead Babies" "For the time being, no matter what happened, I was a really good girlfriend to you and you were a great boyfriend," Love Hewitt told Daly. "We had a lot of fun and it was a good time in our lives and we should end it like that." "It really was," Daly conceded, adding, "It ended a little weird, I gotta be honest." "It did," Love Hewitt admitted, "but that doesn't matter." Agree to disagree? Still, it's clearly water under the bridge. Daly congratulated his ex after learning that she was expecting her first child with then-fiancé Brian Hallisay in 2013. "I wish her healthy motherhood," he told Us Weekly. Jeff Kravitz/FilmMagic In 2018, Love Hewitt celebrated the MTV Video Music Awards with a fitting throwback of her and Daly on the red carpet 20 years prior. Where They Are Now: Daly is now a father of four: Jackson, Etta, London, and Goldie. He wed longtime girlfriend Siri Pinter in late 2015. The TV personality has been hosting NBC's The Voice since 2011. Love Hewitt wed Hallisay in late 2013 — five days before she gave birth to their first child: Autumn. The Client List alum and her former co-star have since welcomed two more children together: Atticus and Aidan. The actress currently stars in fan-favorite Fox drama 9-1-1.