10 Stars Reveal their First Celebrity Crushes

“Alex Rodriguez. I grew up in Seattle, and at the time he was 18 or 19 when he was playing, so he was such a young buck. He was my first crush. John and I saw him at Soho House the other day and I had never seen him in person before, and John is very well aware. He was like, ‘Your man is over there!’ And I was so embarrassed. You just never think you are going to run into those people. But John’s was Tatiana Ali—I'll call him out on that one, too. He had posters and everything."

“Probably like most 13-year-olds, I was pretty interested in Leo [Dicaprio] in Romeo and Juliet. I think every teenage girl just thought, ‘I want that crazy kind of love,’ because you’re just starting to feel it.”

“My first celebrity crush was Olivia Newton-John—but not the sexy one. I liked the Sandra-Dee in her bobby socks.”

“Leo DiCaprio. When I was 13-years-old, I really thought I was going to marry him. I actually carried around a folder of pictures I had printed out from the Internet of him. I kissed his picture every night before I went to bed. I was really sure that one day we would be together."

“Eddie Furlong in Terminator, because he had that long sweet skater haircut. That’s the first one I can remember being like, ‘Ooh, that guy is so cute!’”

“Michael Jackson. I loved him—the way he danced, the way he sang. I thought he was everything."

“Cyndi Lauper. I loved her when I was little. She’s so unique and so different, and I was obsessed with her. I thought she was so cool."

“My first celebrity crush was Jon Bon Jovi. He looked like a woman, but he was also a rock star. There was something very acceptable about him."

“Brian Bloom, because there’s nobody more beautiful. Ever.”

“Zac Hanson. I was very low key and played it cool, but I would just imagine marrying him in my head at like seven-years-old.”

“Growing up, Gene Wilder. He made me laugh so hard, and I just thought he was the most genius, hilarious man. He was my big crush when I was little, and Young Frankenstein is a movie I cannot wait to share with my son.”

“I think my first celebrity crush was the boy band B2K. I was obsessed with them—the whole band was my first crush."