The 10 Best Under-Eye Masks of 2023

You can kiss tired under-eyes goodbye with Wander Beauty Baggage Claim Rose Gold Eye Masks.

In This Article

Jump to a Section

In This Article

We independently research, test, review, and recommend the best products—learn more about our process. If you buy something through our links, we may earn a commission.

Best Under Eye Masks

InStyle / David Hattan

For as long as I can remember I’ve suffered from puffy under-eyes — no matter how much sleep I get or how much water I drink. As I’ve gotten older, dark circles have entered the mix, too. And while incorporating depuffing eye creams (and the occasional espresso shot) into my routine has helped, sometimes I need an immediate fix — and that’s where under-eye masks come in.

Under-eye masks are a smaller version of your normal sheet mask, except they’re geared to specifically treat the delicate eye area. They’re a great intro into the world of skincare, but because of that there are countless options available. That’s why I scoured the internet and tried out dozens of under-eye patches to see which ones can really make a difference.

Out of all of them, we found Wander Beauty Baggage Claim Rose Gold Eye Masks to be the most effective at banishing dark circles, brightening the under-eye area, and reducing puffiness. But they are just one of 10 impressive eye masks. No matter your eye concern, keep reading to find the best under-eye masks.

Best Overall

Wander Beauty Baggage Claim Rose Gold Eye Masks

Wander Beauty Baggage Claim Rose Gold Eye Masks

Sephora

What We Love: These masks feature three key layers (as opposed to one) that deliver lasting results.
What We Don’t Love:
The visible results aren’t as instant as we’d like them to be.

Sure, cute under-eye masks are fun to throw on for a quick hydration boost, but the best ones also go above and beyond to banish dark circles, brighten, and firm the delicate eye area. Wander Beauty Baggage Claim Rose Gold Eye Masks manage to do all that and more, and it’s thanks, in part, to the impressive three layer design.  

While many under-eye masks are made of one serum-infused layer, these feature three: First, the soft inner layer delivers a potent serum to the skin, the middle elastic layer ensures the masks stay securely in place (no slipping or sliding here), and the outer foil keeps everything locked into the skin to ensure the serum and all its benefits are adequately absorbed for the best results possible.

Though I didn’t initially see results after trying these masks, I did feel the cooling effects from the aloe, calendula, and lavender extract-infused serum. I experienced visible results hours later: Despite getting minimal sleep after testing the patches, not only were my dark circles barely visible come morning, but the area under my eyes also looked significantly brighter and felt much more firm. These have since become a staple in my routine.

As an added bonus, the masks are great for travel — slap these on before you take off you’ll be bright-eyed by the time you land.

Price at time of publish: $26

Key Ingredients: Aloe leaf juice, Calendula extract, and Camu camu extract | Benefits: Firms and brightens | Count: 6 pairs

Best Budget

Burt's Bees Renew Natural Hydrogel Eye Mask

Burt's Bees Renew Natural Hydrogel Eye Mask

Target

What We Love: These soothe and revitalize under-eyes in 10 minutes flat.
What We Don’t Love:
There’s only one pair per package. 

Affordable yet powerful, these nourishing eye patches soothe in depuff in just 10 minutes (yep, you read that right). Made with vitamin E and algae extract, the essence in these masks quickly sinks into the delicate eye area to instantaneously reduce swelling, hydrate, and soften skin. The hydrogel texture also amplifies the soothing effect, so you start to feel refreshed from the moment you put these on.

Note that these masks are very slippery, so I recommend wearing them while laying down to ensure they stay in place (and to reap the most benefits). Because there’s only one set per package, these are especially great for travel, but I do wish there were multi-pack options available.

Price at time of publish: $5

Key Ingredients: Algae extract and Vitamin E | Benefits: Hydrates and depuffs | Count: 1 pair

Best Splurge

Kat Burki KB5 Eye Recovery Masks

Kat Burki KB5 Eye Recovery Masks

Bloomingdales

What We Love: Because these patches are made from cloth they don’t slide off your face. 
What We Don’t Love:
Due to the firming ingredients, skin can feel a bit tight after wearing these.

To rejuvenate your under-eyes after a big event, the Kat Burki KB5 Eye Recovery Masks are a splurge-worthy option that come to the rescue time and time again. "These are the first things I grab after a long night out,” says InStyle’s Commerce Editor, Mary Honkus. “In 15 minutes flat the soothing patches make tired, dark circles disappear like magic.” 

The secret lies in the unique combination of plant stem cells and cold-pressed avocado oil: The former works to minimize signs of aging and improve overall skin tone, while the latter intensifies the results because it increases collagen production, which in turn makes skin appear more plump.

“Most eye patches I've tried have a gel consistency, but I like that these are like fabric because they stay in place and don't slide down my face at all,” Honkus adds. 

After massaging the remaining serum into skin, you might experience a tight feeling — fret not as it’s the ingredients working their magic, and the sensation will fade within a few minutes.

Price at time of publish: $90

 Key Ingredients: Botanical Hyaluronic Acid and Cold-pressed avocado oil | Benefits: Soothes and depuffs | Count: 8 pairs

Best for Dark Circles

Pixi BeautifEYE Brightening Eye Patches

Pixi BeautifEYE Brightening Eye Patches

Ulta

What We Love: After wearing these for 10 to 15 minutes, under-eyes look significantly brighter.
What We Don’t Love:
The licorice scent is a bit overpowering. 

If you’re like me and suffer from dark circles no matter how much sleep you seem to get, then these patches will be the solution to your tired-eyed woes. Together, vitamin C and licorice work as a dynamic duo to instantly brighten and energize the under-eye area while also evening out skin tone for a fresh-faced, revitalized look.

The patches should last you through countless long nights, too, because each container comes with 30 pairs. We appreciate that each tub comes with an included spatula — an underappreciated feature that allows you to carefully pull out each mask and reduce the risk of tearing. 

While these are suitable for all skin types — including sensitive skin — it’s worth mentioning that these have a strong licorice scent. So, if you’re more sensitive to fragrance you may want to choose something else. 

Price at time of publish: $24

Key Ingredients: Vitamin C and Licorice | Benefits: Brightens | Count: 30 pairs

Best for Nighttime

Patchology FlashPatch Restoring Night Eye Gels

Patchology FlashPatch Restoring Night Eye Gels

Amazon

What We Love: Retinol is the main ingredient in the formula.
What We Don’t Love:
The serum leaves a slightly sticky residue on the skin.

Normally under-eye patches can be worn at any time, but these were specifically made to be worn at night due to the star ingredient: Retinol. The powerful active, which speeds up cellular turnover, works its magic to reduce fine lines on more mature skin while also minimizing the appearance of dark circles. Along with retinol, these impressive masks are also infused with peptides and arnica extract to reduce crow’s feet and inflammation, as well as de-puff. 

These patches only require about five minutes of wear to begin to see results. And though they have a gel texture, they stay in place (read: you won’t have to worry about them sliding down your face). If I had to pick one thing I didn’t like about this product, it’s the slightly sticky feeling it leaves. To remedy this, be sure to tap in the excess and follow up with an eye cream.

Price at time of publish: $20

Key Ingredients: Retinol, Peptides, and Arnica extract | Benefits: Reduces fine lines and dark circles | Count: 5 pairs

Best for Morning

Milk Makeup Cooling Water Eye Patches

4.9
Milk Makeup Cooling Water Eye Patches

Milk Makeup

What We Love: These under-eye masks instantly de-puff.
What We Don’t Love:
These aren’t as serum-saturated as other eye masks on our list. 

Caffeine doesn’t just wake you up when it’s ingested, it’s also proven to energize skin when used topically as well – and it happens to be the main ingredient in the Milk Makeup Cooling Water Eye Patches. When applied, the caffeine in these eye masks increases circulation to under-eyes, which in turn soothes and hydrates the area.

Other ingredients, such as natural seawater, aloe, and lavender, are used to add a boost of hydration, while also working to soothe and de-puff — which is super important when puffiness is more common in the mornings after waking up. These masks will ultimately make your eyes look and feel more refreshed. But that’s not all: The best part about Milk Makeup products is that they are completely vegan and cruelty-free, so you can feel good about your purchase, too.. 

Though this isn’t inherently a bad thing, It’s worth noting that these eye masks aren’t as serum-saturated as other options on this list, so they dry out more quickly when wearing. 

Price at time of publish: $22

Key Ingredients: Caffeine | Benefits: Soothes, depuffs, and hydrates | Count: 6 pairs

Best Reusable

Dieux Skin Forever Eye Mask

Dieux Skin Forever Eye Mask

DieuxSkin

What We Love: These reusable patches can be used over 1000 (!) times.
What We Don’t Love:
The masks need to be cleaned so they don’t harbor bacteria. 

If I could only wear one pair of under-eye patches for the rest of my life, this would be it — seriously! Dieux Skin Forever Eye Masks are reusable silicone eye patches that can be worn over and over again (over 1000 times to be exact). After going through your regular skin routine, apply your favorite eye cream or serum to your skin, then place the masks over top — they will ensure your skin products stay in place, and actually increase absorption so you can get the most out of your skincare. After about 20 minutes, you can remove them, rinse, and then place them back in their case.

To ensure they stay sanitary and in pristine condition, you’ll want to clean them after each use. The cleaning process is pretty simple (with just a rinse), but make sure they’re completely dry before storing.

Price at time of publish: $25

Key Ingredients: Silicone | Benefits: Reusable, helps products sink into skin | Count: 1 pair

Best Hydrating

Peter Thomas Roth Water Drench Hyaluronic Cloud Hydra-Gel Eye Patches

default image

What We Love: These are ideal for all skin types, but are especially great for parched, dehydrated skin.
What We Don’t Love: 
These have a tendency to slip and slide around your face. 

The skin under your eyes is the most delicate area on your face — meaning it’s more susceptible to drying out. When I’m feeling extra parched, I always look to these masks to quench my under-eyes thirst. They’re full of hydrating ingredients including glycerin and hyaluronic acid, which both draw moisture into the area to help under-eyes look and feel more hydrated. Additionally, these masks also contain caffeine to soothe and de-puff, and marshmallow root extract to soften skin.

Since these eye masks are larger than others and have a gel texture, they’re not the best at staying in place. Also, the size makes them difficult to place, especially if you have more of a petite facial structure. I recommend cutting them to better fit your face (plus, you’ll be left with more patches in the end). 

Price at time of publish: $55

Key Ingredients: Hyaluronic acid, Marshmallow root extract, and Caffeine | Benefits: Hydrates | Count: 30 pairs

Best for Eye Bags

Winky Lux Wakey Wakey Hydrogel Eye Patches

Winky Lux Wakey Wakey Hydrogel Eye Patches

Amazon

What We Love: Infused with hyaluronic acid, these patches dramatically increase hydration (plus the star design is super cute). 
What We Don’t Love:
These eye masks dry out quickly.

Woke up with serious eye bags? These will make them disappear in minutes. The immediate cooling sensation of these under-eye masks is what initially sold me, but the lasting results is what keeps me reaching for them again and again. Together, caffeine, Vitamin C, and hyaluronic acid work to depuff, brighten, and awaken tired under-eyes. 

Though they can be used at any time of day, I enjoy using these masks right when I wake up because they act as my eyes’ morning coffee. Plus, the cute star design is an instant mood booster, too. Pro tip: Store them in the fridge to enhance the soothing feeling.

While the instructions say to wear these for 10 minutes, I noticed that the serum completely soaked into my skin after about five minutes of wear. This could just be because my under-eyes are extremely dry, but it’s still something to consider before purchasing.

Price at time of publish: $22

Key Ingredients: Caffeine, Vitamin C, and Hyaluronic Acid | Benefits: Cools and depuffs | Count: 30 pairs

Best Gold

Skin Gym Red Carpet VIP Gold Foil Eye Mask

Skin Gym Red Carpet VIP Gold Foil Eye Mask

Skin Gym

What We Love: These multi-tasking eye masks address an array of skin concerns, including fine lines and dryness.
What We Don’t Love:
A decent amount of serum is left in the bottom of each packet.

Believe it or not, the use of foil does more than add a style factor to eye masks. In fact, foil is often used to help lock in the serum and retain moisture to keep the delicate eye area hydrated. And while we love the gold foil aspect of these patches, it’s just the cherry on top to an effective formula.

Featuring bakuchiol (a natural retinol alternative found in nature) and CoQ10 (a powerful skin compound loaded with antioxidants), these two ingredients brighten, tighten, reduce fine lines, and completely re-energize skin. And if you struggle with dryness, these masks are also infused with hyaluronic acid to hydrate the delicate area. 

While I found these masks to be pretty saturated upon opening, I did notice that there was a significant amount of serum left inside each packet — don’t let this go to waste! Even after removing the masks, tap the excess into your eyes. I always do this and find I get better results by using the extra serum. 

Price at time of publish: $18

Key Ingredients: Bakuchiol, CoQ10, and Hyaluronic acid | Benefits: Brightens and hydrates | Count: 5 pairs

What to Keep in Mind

Skin Concern

Regardless of any skin concerns, using eye masks is a great way to refresh the delicate eye area, and they’re ideal for all skin types. But if you do have specific concerns, you’ll want to keep an eye out for certain ingredients to get the results you want. “Hyaluronic acid, retinol, vitamin C, and caffeine are some of my top essentials when it comes to eye masks,” says Taylor Worden, celebrity esthetician and founder of Taylor Worden Skin.

If your under-eye area tends to dry out, Worden recommends looking for eye masks infused with hyaluronic acid, like Peter Thomas Roth Water Drench Hyaluronic Cloud Hydra-Gel Eye Patches. This water-binding ingredient attracts moisture into the skin to hydrate and plump the area. While hyaluronic acid also helps to reduce fine lines and wrinkles, opt for eye masks with retinol for longer-lasting results (we like Patchology FlashPatch Restoring Night Eye Gels).

On the other hand, to combat dark circles look for patches that contain vitamin C, like Pixi BeautifEYE Brightening Eye Patches. The brightening agent minimizes the appearance of tired eyes to make it look like you got a full night sleep. And if you struggle with puffy eyes, caffeine works to instantly de-puff. Try using Milk Makeup Cooling Water Eye Patches for near instantaneous results.

Material 

While gel eye patches are the most common, there are also patches made with fabric and foil, too. Gel eye patches are great because the serum sits on top, which allows it to seamlessly sink into skin rather than staying stuck on the eye patch material. However, gel textures have a tendency to slide down your face, so you may want to lay down while wearing them to ensure they stay in place.

If you hate when eye patches slip and slide around your face, opt for fabric masks, like Kat Burki KB5 Eye Recovery Masks. This material has a good grip and will stay in place while wearing. Foil, on the other hand, doesn't really affect the staying power of the mask itself, but it locks in heat and moisture, so masks with foil finishes are ideal if you really want to see near immediate results because the serum underneath is less likely to evaporate.

Your Questions, Answered

How do you apply under eye patches? 

The most important part of the application process is preparing the eye area — you want to ensure that your face is totally clean before placing an under-eye mask on your face. “After removing all makeup and dirt, gently apply the under-eye patches,” says Jeannette Graf, M.D., board-certified dermatologist and Assistant Clinical Professor of Dermatology at Mount Sinai School of Medicine. If makeup isn’t removed, then the product on the patches won’t be able to soak into the skin. 

If your masks are housed in a jar, it’s important to use the spatula provided when taking them out of a container — this will prevent them from tearing and ensure that the serum stays soaked into the patch. If they’re in a packet, carefully slide them out and grab the thickest part of the patch, then apply to your face.

How do under eye patches work?

“All patches work by adding a layer of hydration to the skin and then covering it with an occlusive material,” said Nicole Hayre, M.D., a Virginia-based board-certified dermatologist. The main purpose of eye masks is to lock in moisture, and what it’s made out of plays an important role in its effectiveness. Gel, fabric, and foil all work well to hold serums or other skin products in place so that you can get the best results out of the treatment.

While it does depend on the packaging instructions, eye masks are typically worn for about 10 to 15 minutes. I noticed that after testing each product on this list, it took no longer than 10 minutes for the active ingredients to sink into the skin. When the patches are worn longer for 15 minutes, they start to dry out. 

Why Shop With Us

Taylor Bushey has been an avid writer across a range of publications since 2015. She is also a makeup enthusiast and is always trying out the latest products and discovering new trends. On top of conducting market research and testing every product on this list, she reached out to experts including Taylor Worden, celebrity esthetician and founder of Taylor Worden Skin; Jeannette Graf, M.D., board-certified dermatologist and Assistant Clinical Professor of Dermatology at Mount Sinai School of Medicine; and Nicole Hayre, M.D., a Virginia-based board-certified dermatologist to learn more about how under-eye masks works and their benefits for the skin. 

Related Articles