The Best Eyeshadow Colors to Try If You Have Blue Eyes

Plus, how to wear each one.

The Best Eyeshadow Colors for Blue Eyes
Photo: Instagram @goldenbarbie/ Getty Images

The best eyeshadow for your eye color is whatever shade you feel like wearing on that given day, but it's proven that some shadows will enhance certain eye colors more than others.

It all comes down to color theory: colors on opposite sides of the color wheel will complement one another. As for what eyeshadow colors will make blue eyes pop, think warm shades like orange, brown, peach, and terracotta, along with shimmery champagne and rich berry.

"Depending on how dramatic or how natural you're looking to go, I like to use colors that are almost opposites of the eye to create contrast and really bring out the overall eye color," says Neil Scibelli, a New York City-based celebrity makeup artist.

Deciding on an eyeshadow color is only one half of the equation. Eddie Duyos, Make Up For Ever Pro Makeup Artist & Senior Manager of Pro Education & Artistry, suggests considering what vibe you want to give off with your makeup.

"I like to approach it [eye makep] like a game. It's more of, 'who do I want to be today? Do I want to feel powerful, or am I feeling more subtle and romantic? What is it that I want the world see today?'" Duyos shares. "Aside from the normal makeup concerns like skin type, breakouts, discoloration, etc., have fun with makeup no matter what anyone says, and allow it to help you be and feel the best version of yourself every day."

With that in mind, both makeup artists break down the eyeshadow colors that really make blue eyes standout. See how celebrities are wearing the shades on the red carpet to get inspiration for your own eye makeup looks.

VIDEO: Here's How to Properly Clean and Dry Your Makeup Brushes

01 of 09

Warm Brown Eyeshadow

Alexa Chung at the Chloe Fall/Winter 2021 Fashion Show
Pascal Le Segretain/Getty Images

Warm shades of brown are a beautiful everyday look for blue eyes. For a quick and easy way to wear the shade, Duyos suggests dusting a wash of shadow across the lids, then lining the upper and lower lids with a darker chestnut pencil liner for definition. With Make Up For Ever's Aqua Resist Color Pencil in Ebony, you won't worry about smudges or flakes.

02 of 09

Peach Eyeshadow

Julia Garner at the Kate Spade S/S 2020 Fashion Show
Aurora Rose/Patrick McMullan via Getty Images

Not only is this winged-out peach eyeshadow right on trend, (and way easier to do than traditional cat-eye liner) it brightens baby blue eyes. The peachy tones of Fenty Beauty's Snap Shadows Mix & Match Eyeshadow Palette in Peach are ideal for recreating Julia Garner's look by makeup artist Hung Vanngo.

03 of 09

Smudged Eyeliner

Sarah Jessica Parker at the And Just Like That Premiere
Dimitrios Kambouris/Getty Images

"One of my favorite bold looks on blue eyes is the 'SJP,' which is a dark brown or black eyeliner or shadow smudged on the top and lower line," says Scibelli. "It creates the perfect smoky, sultry look for blue eyes." Here, Sarah Jessica Parker paired her smudgy eyeliner with chocolate brown eyeshadow on the lids as a base.

As for which liner to use, we're fans of Pat McGrath Labs' PermaGel Eyeliner Pencil. It can be sharpened like a kohl pencil, but has the silky smooth texture of a gel liner with amply play time for smudging.

04 of 09

Shimmery Champagne Eyeshadow

For a hint of shimmer that'll really make blue eyes pop when it catches the light, look no further than champagne eyeshadow. "Champagnes, light coppers, and rose golds are my neutral go-to's for blue eyes," Scibelli says. "They create the perfect neutral backdrop for light eyes and really bring out the various hues of the eye color."

Simply tap a shiny shadow like Victoria Beckham Beauty's Lid Lustre in Chiffon on your lids with your fingertip, apply a few coats of mascara, and you're good to go.

05 of 09

Terracotta Eyeshadow

It might not be the first color you'd gravitate towards in an eyeshadow palette, but orange-y terracotta looks drop dead gorgeous on blue eyes. Take Margot Robbie's monochromatic look by Pati Dubroff for example.

Create your own take on terracotta eyes with About-Face's Matte Fluid Eye Paint in Light Transcending. The liquid formula is made to last, and dries down to a soft powder that doesn't crease, fade, or smear.

06 of 09

Plum Smoky Eyeshadow

Dakota Johnson at the Academy Of Motion Picture Arts And Sciences' 11th Annual Governors Awards
Steve Granitz/WireImage

The rich undertones of plum eyeshadow perfectly contrast cool blue eyes. Smoke out the shadow for an edgy, unexpected twist on the classic eye makeup technique. "To ease into a bold variation, I like using plum shades on blue eyes, which can be worn as a smoky plum look or even just a light wash of a plum – it really makes blue eyes pop," Scibelli shares.

The berry shades in Natasha Denona's Retro Eyeshadow Palette do the mixing and matching for you.

07 of 09

Orange Eyeliner

Let Gigi Hadid convince you to step out of your comfort zone and try neon orange eye makeup. The color is one of Duyos's favorites for blue eyes, who says it will turn up the color of blue eyes to a higher level. "Depending on the eye shape, a great way to intensify blue eyes is by adding a sharp orange wing liner or doing a smoky orange lower lash line," the makeup artist says. Applying the color to the inner corners is another option.

Try tapping on Make Up For Ever's Artist Color Shadow in ME 734 Tangerine on the inner corners of the eyes, then finish off with a few coats of Maybelline's Volum' Express Colossal Curl Bounce Mascara.

08 of 09

Charcoal Smoky Eyeshadow

Kirsten Dunst at the 74th Annual Directors Guild Of America Awards
Steve Granitz/FilmMagic

When in doubt, a charcoal smoky eye is always a good idea on blue eyes. Scibelli loves using the shade for an evening look.

Here, make Kirsten Dunst's classic charcoal eye your own with Chanel's Le 4 Ombres Eyeshadow Palette in Modern Glamour.

09 of 09

Navy Blue Eyeshadow

"For an evening look, I love using shades of navy and deep charcoals, which also really bring out the blues of the eyes," Scibelli says.

Makeup artist Lottie used navy for Alexandra Daddario's smoky eye, then further brightened her blue eyes by adding champagne eyeshadow to her inner corners and tapping it on the middle of her lid for dimension. Pat McGrath Labs' Celestial Divinity Eyeshadow Palette in Interstellar Icon conveniently has similar shades to do the look on your own.

Related Articles