7 Unexpected Makeup Shades that Are Actually Flattering

By Erin Lukas Updated Mar 02, 2016 @ 6:00 pm

Each product we feature has been independently selected and reviewed by our editorial team. If you make a purchase using the links included, we may earn commission.

Skip gallery slides

Credit: Courtesy

Have you ever been shopping for new makeup shades and came across a color that's stopped you dead in the middle of the beauty aisle with this thought: "Who the heck would wear that?" We're right there with you scratching our heads.

But despite initially writing off these products off as best suited for clowns, many of these intimidating hues actually go on a little more tame and all-around flattering than on first impression. A vivid turquoise eyeliner will brighten and accentuate your eyes, and a blush that matches the shade of your favorite red lipstick actually leaves a natural, healthy flush on the apples of your cheeks. Here, seven seemingly wacky-colored products that can easily be incorporated into your makeup routine for a welcome splash of color.

Start Slideshow

1 of 7

NARS Cosmetics Blush in Exhibit A

Credit: Courtesy

You might think that the bold red hue of this NARS blush is better suited for your lips, but the powder actually produces a healthy, natural-looking flush. Just apply with a light hand to gradually build the shade desired.

$30; narscosmetics.com

2 of 7

Lipstick Queen Lipstick in Hello Sailor

Credit: Courtesy

When we first saw this blue lipstick, images of frost bitten lips instantly came to mind, but this navy bullet unexpectedly goes on super sheer as a flattering deep berry tint that will also make teeth look extra bright.

$25; lipstickqueen.com

3 of 7

Yves Saint Laurent Mascara Volume Effet Faux Cils in Hippie Green

Credit: Courtesy

This green hue may seem better suited for a Wizard of Oz costume, but hear us out: Emerald green lashes will compliment warm brown eyes and enhance the golden flecks in blue and green eyes.

$32; yslbeautyus.com

4 of 7

RMS Lip2cheek in Curious

Credit: Courtesy

Yes it’s bright and orange, but this cheek balm is totally wearable and leaves behind a sheer, buildable glow that works on a number of skin tones.

$36; rmsbeauty.com

5 of 7

Essence Long-Lasting Eye Pencil in Tu-Tu Turquoise 17

Credit: Courtesy

Surprisingly, a turquoise liner is a flattering shade for every skin tone and eye color. Glide this pencil on close to your waterline for a subtle boost of color, or be extra playful and use it to create a cat eye.

$3; ulta.com

6 of 7

NYX Cosmetics Full Throttle Shadow Stick in Femme Fatale

Credit: Courtesy

It’s easy to be intimidated by a rich purple shadow, but if you give the shade a chance, you’ll find the vivid color is universally complimentary and can be worn day or night.

$7; nyxcosmetics.com

7 of 7

Too Cool For School Dinoplatz Lost Identity Lip Color

Credit: Courtesy

Mint green isn’t known for being a go-to lip shade, but this mood ring-like crayon is about to change that. Once you swipe it on, the color adjusts based on your body chemistry. Bonus: it keeps lips soft and smooth all day long.

$18; sephora.com

Replay gallery

Up Next

By Erin Lukas

If the Coastal Grandmother Trend Isn't for You, How About Its Alternative, Fancy Grandma?

It Seems Like Everyone Has False Lashes These Days — Here's Why

8 Ways to Wear a Sheer Lace Dress, According to Stylists

7 Unexpected Makeup Shades that Are Actually Flattering