Say what you will about social media celebrities, but Jeffree Star just might have been the one to start the category back when Tom from MySpace was a member of your friends list. Today, you can find Star's expansive makeup line adorning just about everyone on your Instagram feed, and although the products sell out minutes after going live on the site, restocks are frequent, and the makeup artist lets his loyal followers know via social media exactly when to expect the next batch to roll out. In recent months, Star continued to tease the launch of his Skin Frost highlighters, and after seeing them in action on his video tutorials, we knew we had to get our hands on them. Once we acquired all four hues, we asked four of our InStyle staffers to see how they look IRL. Scroll down to see how the highlighters look, and continue stalking Starr's Twitter and Instagram to find out when his next restock will go live.