The Best Drugstore Mascaras for All Your Lash Needs

By Erin Lukas
Updated Feb 04, 2016 @ 5:00 pm
Each product we feature has been independently selected and reviewed by our editorial team. If you make a purchase using the links included, we may earn commission.
Credit: Courtesy

Without a doubt, mascara is one the hardest-working products in our kit. It’s often the quickest cure-all for a plethora of beauty emergencies. From looking like less of a zombie, to hitting snooze too many times, to making eyes appear bigger, a few swipes of mascara has the power to instantly make us look awake and put-together.

While it may only take a minute to actually apply mascara, finding the formula that’s the perfect match for your lashes is a little more time consuming, and (since wands have to be replaced more frequently than other products) pricey—if you’re partial to high-end brands.

RELATED: The Best Eyelash Conditioners to Get Strong, Healthy Lashes Fast

If you’re looking to save some cash in the mascara department, you’re in luck. Some of the best formulas can be found in the aisles of your local drugstore and deliver the same lash-enhancing benefits as your current fancy wand. Read on for high-performance mascaras that won’t leave you penniless.

Start Slideshow

1 of 8

Sensitive Eyes

Credit: Courtesy
$8
SHOP IT

Physicians Formula Organic Wear 100% Natural Origin mascara is all-natural right down to its recyclable packaging. That doesn’t, however, mean it skimps on lengthening and plumping, so it’s a no-brainer for sensitive eyes.

Advertisement
Advertisement

2 of 8

Clump-Resistant

Credit: Courtesy
$8
SHOP IT

CoverGirl’s Clump Crusher mascara doesn’t just stomp away clumps—it prevents them. Use its curved brush for smooth, defined lashes with every single application.

3 of 8

Curling

Credit: Courtesy
$8
SHOP IT

Even if you’re a seasoned veteran with an eyelash curler, sometimes your lashes need an extra curve. Rimmel London Wonderful Lift Me Up mascara will give lashes an extra lift that will have you considering retiring your curler to your bathroom drawer.

Advertisement

4 of 8

Lash Lengthening

Credit: Courtesy
$8
SHOP IT

The name says it all: Almay’s Get Up And mascara instantly elongates lashes while nourishing them with a formula that also helps strengthen lashes over time.

5 of 8

Do-It-All

Credit: Courtesy
$6
SHOP IT

Give your eyelash curler a rest. Revlon’s Ultimate All-In-One is a highly pigmented, multitasking mascara that lifts, defines, and lengthens lashes in a just a few simple swipes.

6 of 8

Water-Resistant

Credit: Courtesy
$9
SHOP IT

Many waterproof mascaras are prone to drying out lashes and causing breakage. The secret behind L’Oréal Paris Voluminous Million Lashes Waterproof mascara is a formula that conditions as it gives you your best lashes yet, through water, rain, tears, or sweat.

Advertisement
Advertisement
Advertisement

7 of 8

Lower Lashes

Credit: Courtesy
$7
SHOP IT

The ultra slim brush of NYX’s The Skinny mascara makes it ideal for defining and lengthening the lower lash line, and zoning-in on hard to reach lashes.

8 of 8

Maximum Volume

Credit: Courtesy
$8
SHOP IT

Multiply your fringe with Maybelline New York Volum’ Express Falsies Big Eyes mascara. One end of the double-sided brush has a plush bristles specifically for your top lashes, while the skinnier end caters to the lower lash line where tiny hairs can easily be swiped over.

Replay gallery

Share the Gallery

Up Next

By Erin Lukas