Shopping

These 16 Mascaras Make Short Lashes Look Super Long 

Thousands of shoppers say these are the best of the best. 
By Rebecca Carhart
Aug 24, 2020 @ 10:34 am
Each product we feature has been independently selected and reviewed by our editorial team. If you make a purchase using the links included, we may earn commission.
  • Best Overall Option:
    Too Faced Better Than Sex Mascara
    $25
    SHOP IT
    sephora.com
  • Best Waterproof Option:
    Covergirl Lash Blast Volume Waterproof Mascara
    $7
    SHOP IT
    amazon.com
  • Best Drugstore Option:
    Maybelline New York Volum’ Express Pumped Up Mascara
    $7
    SHOP IT
    amazon.com
  • Best Luxury Option:
    Chanel Le Volume de Chanel Mascara
    $32
    SHOP IT
    nordstrom.com
  • Best Fiber Option:
    Dior Diorshow Lash-Extension Effect Volume Mascara
    $30
    SHOP IT
    nordstrom.com
  • Best Clean Option:
    Honest Beauty Extreme Length Mascara
    $17
    SHOP IT
    amazon.com
  • Best Cruelty-Free Option:
    Essence Lash Princess Mascara
    $5
    SHOP IT
    amazon.com
  • Best Long-Lasting Option:
    Tarte Lights, Camera, Lashes 4-in-1 Mascara
    $23
    SHOP IT
    sephora.com
  • Best Lengthening Option:
    Lancome Definicils Lengthening & Defining Mascara
    $28
    SHOP IT
    ulta.com
  • Best Volumizing Option:
    Milk Makeup Kush High Volume Mascara
    $24
    SHOP IT
    sephora.com
  • Best Natural-Looking Option:
    Maybelline Full ‘N Soft Mascara
    $8
    SHOP IT
    amazon.com
  • Best Curling Option:
    Benefits Cosmetics Roller Lash Curling & Lifting Mascara
    $25
    SHOP IT
    ulta.com
  • Best Buildable Option:
    Lancome Hypnose Custom Volume Mascara
    $28
    SHOP IT
    sephora.com
  • Best Strengthening Option:
    Tarte Gifted Amazonian Clay Smart Mascara
    $23
    SHOP IT
    sephora.com
  • Best Smudge-Proof Option:
    Benefit Cosmetics They’re Real! Lengthening and Volumizing Mascara
    $25
    SHOP IT
    sephora.com
  • Best Option for Lower Lashes:
    Clinique Bottom Lash Mascara
    $12
    SHOP IT
    ulta.com

Whether you like them to be perfectly curled or you’re partial to thick, voluminous lashes, one thing most women can agree on is they wish their eyelashes were longer. Luckily there’s a mascara out there to help you achieve the extra-long lashes of your dreams.

When choosing a mascara, it’s important to find an option that will not only make your eyes pop and your eyelashes more defined, but also one that is formulated to help your specific lash needs. Some are infused with ingredients that help strengthen lashes, which will help them grow longer, while others are made with microfiber-infused formulas that give you the look of extra-long lash extensions

To help you find the right mascara for your short lashes, we scoured thousands of reviews from real shoppers to find out which mascaras they love the most. These beloved beauty products not only have near-perfect ratings, they also have an overwhelming number of glowing customer reviews between them.

From affordable mascaras to waterproof options to one that’s specially made for the lower lashline, we’ve rounded up 16 top-rated mascaras that customers said made their short and stubby lashes look ultra-long. Keep reading to shop them all. 

These are the best mascaras for short lashes to shop: 

Courtesy

Not only does this Too Faced mascara have over 16,000 customer reviews, it has more than 437,000 likes at Sephora. The top-rated mascara comes with an hourglass-shaped brush that is designed to apply the collagen-infused formula evenly. Along with being smudge-proof, the mascara is also buildable so you can apply as many coats as you like to achieve your desired length. “I have tried many mascaras as I have very short eyelashes that don’t curl,” wrote one shopper. “This is by far the best I have used as it actually makes my lashes curl and look full! Never using any other mascara again.”

Shop now: $25; sephora.com

Courtesy CVS

Looking for a lengthening mascara that’s also waterproof? Check out this Covergirl option. The popular mascara comes in five different shades and is specially formulated to lengthen lashes and make them look fuller, without leaving behind any flakes or clumps. It’s also cruelty-free and affordable. With details like that, it’s no wonder that over 2,000 Amazon customers have given it a five-star rating. “I am super impressed,” wrote one. “I have tiny short lashes and these LENGTHEN a lot while also giving volume. It does not fade and it doesn’t ever flake on my under eye even in very hot, humid weather. It truly holds up amazingly throughout the day.” 

Shop now: $7; amazon.com

Courtesy

If you’re in the market for a top-rated mascara that won’t break the bank, hundreds of Amazon customers recommend this Maybelline option. According to the brand, the mascara’s innovative brush makes your lashes look 12 times more voluminous when applying the collagen-infused mascara smoothly from root to tip. Plus, shoppers love that the volumizing product is super easy to remove and is less than $10 a tube. “I have short and thin lashes and I’ve tried everything,” said one reviewer. “ THIS PRODUCT IS AMAZING! It gives me volume, length, separation, fullness, AND it actually adheres to the lashes — even on the ends of the lashes.”

Shop now: $7; amazon.com

Courtesy

Over 1,000 Nordstorm shoppers are fans of this luxe mascara from Chanel. In addition to making your lashes longer with a single application, the beauty product will also darken your eyelashes to make your eyes really pop. Its beloved mascara wand uses both short and long bristles to create length and volume. “There is just nothing that compares. This is a luxury item for sure, but it goes on so clean yet makes my lashes look full, soft, and jet black. I love it,” raved one shopper. 

Shop now: $32; nordstrom.com

Courtesy

This top-rated mascara from Dior is infused with microfibers that adhere to your lashes to make them look noticeably longer and thicker. Not only does it come in three different colors, the product also boasts the brand’s patented air-lock wiper, which prevents the mascara from drying out — allowing you to get your full money’s worth. One happy customer wrote, “This is the best mascara I’ve ever used. I get asked if my lashes are extensions. This is amazing and lasts!!”

Shop now: $30; nordstrom.com

Courtesy Target

If you prefer to use clean beauty products, consider investing in this option by Honest Beauty. The two-in-one product works as both a mascara and a primer to give you extra-long lashes and is infused with jojoba esters, which help moisturize and strengthen your eyelashes. What’s more, the mascara is made without any parabens, paraffins, silicones, and synthetic fragrances, and it’s dermatologist and ophthalmologist-tested, and toxicologist-verified. “I LOVE THIS MASCARA,” raved one shopper. “I used to use toxic mascara and I would need two to three different mascaras to get the results this one mascara does. Even then this mascara does it better! My eyelashes are soooo long and thick-looking. I love how clean the ingredients are and how amazing this product works.” 

Shop now: $17; amazon.com

Courtesy

With over 29,000 customer reviews, this Essence Lash Princess mascara is one of the most popular options on Amazon. The cruelty-free beauty product has earned praise from shoppers for its volumizing mascara wand, clump-free formula, and affordable price point. Many customers say their eyelashes are so thick and long when they use this mascara, their friends and family think they have false lashes on. “I have short, very thin lashes and for years believed I would only get the best results from a high-end, expensive, name-brand mascara,” said one reviewer. “I was absolutely amazed at how well it worked on my aging, thin, colorless lashes. I just reordered four more and really hope the company will continue production!!”

Shop now: $5; amazon.com

Courtesy

If you need a mascara that will last all day and night, check out this Tarte option. According to the brand, the mascara not only curls, lengthens, conditions, and volumizes lashes, but it does all of that for 24 hours at a time. Even better, the mascara is vegan, cruelty-free, and gluten-free. “Love this mascara,” raved one shopper. “It is my go to mascara and everytime I try another one I always come back to it. I think I have three of them between my home, purse, and car. Lasts all day on me. No issues with flaking, and I constantly get asked what I’m using and if my lashes are real.”

Shop now: $23; sephora.com

Courtesy

Over 2,000 Ulta customers are obsessed with how long this Lancome mascara makes their lashes. Not only does the top-rated mascara lengthen your eyelashes in a very natural-looking way, it is also infused with panthenol and vitamin B5 to condition and hydrate your actual lashes. “This mascara goes on smoothly without clumping,” wrote one reviewer. “Gives my skimpy lashes definition with length and volume! I have not had an issue with flaking or smudging. I do need to use a makeup remover meant for waterproof makeup and have to spend an extra minute on my lashes. But I see that as a good thing!”

Shop now: $28; ulta.com

Courtesy

Pump up the volume with this volumizing mascara by Milk Makeup. The beloved product is infused with heart-shaped fibers and hemp-derived cannabis seed oil, which work together to lengthen and thicken the look of your eyelashes. The mascara is made with pure pigments to darken lashes, and it’s vegan and gluten-free. For these reasons and more, over 92,000 Sephora customers have liked the product, with one happy shopper writing, “I love this mascara. It gives so much volume to the lashes, they look like fake lashes and they are not clumpy at all. I will definitely buy another one in the future.”

Shop now: $24; sephora.com

Courtesy

Prefer your lashes to look natural? Thousands of Amazon shoppers say this Maybelline mascara is your best bet. The popular essential is infused with vitamin E to hydrate your lash line and create a softer, more natural look. Its handy wand expertly separates lashes to apply the product smoothly and clump-free. “This may actually be in the top two or three mascaras I have ever used,” said one shopper. “This mascara lengthens and gives a bit of thickness, but not a fake-looking amount. It just makes my lashes look like better versions of themselves. It looks very natural and stays on all day.”

Shop now: $8; amazon.com

Courtesy

If you love the look of curled lashes, but don’t want to deal with an eyelash curler, this Benefits Cosmetics mascara will be right up your alley. Not only will it leave your lashes with an intense, ink-black finish, it will also lengthen, lift, and curl your eyelashes for up to 12 hours. In a consumer panel survey, 87 percent of users said it gave them a “long-lasting curl,” while 97 percent said it “visibly lifts lashes.” One happy Ulta customer raved, “I can’t use an eyelash curling tool so this mascara is the best invention ever! It makes my eyelashes look naturally curled and they look longer and fuller.”

Shop now: $25; ulta.com

Courtesy

You can easily create both natural daytime looks and more dramatic makeup looks with this buildable mascara by Lancome. According to the brand, with several swipes, you can “achieve 600 percent the volume of your natural lash.” The mascara is infused with vitamin B5 to prevent any flakes or clumping from occurring. “I love love LOVE this mascara,” wrote one reviewer. “I have used so many different mascaras and I always go back to this one. It’s never clumpy and so easy to build. I can do one coat for a natural lash and six coats for length and drama.”

Shop now: $28; sephora.com

Courtesy

While many mascaras contain chemicals that can damage your lashes, this Tarte option is specially formulated with Amazonian clay to strengthen them while you wear it. The clay absorbs any excess oils, which helps promote lash health and regrowth, and it also boosts color pigmentation to leave your lashes with a more intense look. “I have tried every mascara known to man, woman, and child, and I am telling you this is the best mascara hands down! Y’all have been sleeping on this amazing product. Try it, you won't be sad,” said one Sephora customer. 

Shop now: $23; sephora.com

Courtesy

Over 15,000 Sephora customers have given this Benefit Cosmetics mascara their seal of approval for a reason. The award-winning mascara promises to curl, volumize, lift, and separate lashes without smudges or clumping throughout the day. In a consumer panel survey, 100 percent of users said the mascara gave them long-lasting results, and 94 percent said they saw a dramatic increase in length and volume. “Love this mascara,” wrote one shopper. “I only apply one coat and my lashes look amazing! It gives volume and length but still leaves you lashes looking clean and not “overdone.” The brush is great because I’m able to get even my small inner lashes and bottom lashes with no mess.”

Shop now: $25; sephora.com

Courtesy

Lower lashes are much shorter than upper lashes, and it’s typically harder to apply mascara to them, which is why Clinique developed this mascara to give them some much-needed length and volume. Not only does it have an innovative compact wand that delivers a precise application of the mascara to stubby lower lashes, but the mascara itself is specially formulated to be smudge-resistant and not leave streaks under your eyes. “I never thought I would get length for my lower lashes but this little baby does the trick,” raved one shopper. “I am amazed at how long my bottom lashes are when I use this mascara on them. Ladies GO GET THIS MASCARA NOW!!!”

Shop now: $12; ulta.com