Readers' Choice: The Beauty Products You Loved Most This Year

By Angelique Serrano and Dianna Mazzone
Updated Sep 09, 2019 @ 8:00 am
Each product we feature has been independently selected and reviewed by our editorial team. If you make a purchase using the links included, we may earn commission.
Meredith

Not unlike the Olympics, preparing for our annual Readers’ Choice Beauty Awards is a year-round affair. We editors spent our days swatching, sniffing, and slathering on beauty products (okay, maybe it’s a Iittle different than planning the Olympics) that launched between May 2018 and June 2019, all in an effort to determine nominees.

Then we left it up to you, reader, to cast the final vote. (Or shout-out your own top picks using our write-in option.) Nearly 4,500 of you participated in our online survey and professed your love for budge-proof brow products (ahem, Anastasia Beverly Hills Dipbrow Gel), innovative skin-care, and CBD-spiked everything. (It’s the star ingredient in not one but three of our winning formulas.)

RELATED: The Best Anti-Aging Products of 2019

And, as always, we couldn’t help but award some of our personal favorites, too. (Seriously, the Dyson Airwrap is worth every single penny.) Those winners are labeled “Editors’ Picks,” but you can consider them each the Megan Rapinoe of our editors’ beauty product A-teams.

And now, the fun part: Kick back, relax, and explore the 40+ makeup, skin, and hair launches that changed the game this year.

VIDEO: 5 Drugstore Beauty Products Celebs Swear By

Start Slideshow

1 of 42

FOUNDATION: Tarte Babassu Foundcealer

Courtesy
$39
SHOP IT

This vegan base hydrates like a moisturizer, protects with SPF 20, and melts right in.

Advertisement
Advertisement

2 of 42

CONCEALER: Fenty Beauty by Rihanna Pro Filt’r Instant Retouch

Courtesy
$26
SHOP IT

Clearly, Rihanna’s idea of the perfect concealer is a long-wearing, full-coverage, anti-crease formula in 50 shades. And we agree.

3 of 42

BLUSH: Lancôme Le Monochromatique

Courtesy
$25
SHOP IT

In an easy-to-blend cream-to-powder formula, each color delivers a realistic flush.

Advertisement

4 of 42

HIGHLIGHTER: Ilia Liquid Light Serum

Courtesy
$42
SHOP IT

The sheer liquid gives you a fresh glow, not an overdose of glitter.

5 of 42

BRONZER: Fenty Beauty by Rihanna Sun Stalk’r Instant Warmth

Courtesy
$30
SHOP IT

Rihanna’s coveted collection of eight bronzers flatters complexions without streaking or leaving a chalky residue.

6 of 42

EDITOR'S PICK: Perricone MD No Makeup Foundation Serum

Courtesy
$60
SHOP IT

Hate wearing foundation? This fluid will change your mind. The tinted formula not only feels weightless but also conceals discoloration without caking.

Advertisement
Advertisement
Advertisement

7 of 42

BROW PRODUCT: Anastasia Beverly Hills Dipbrow Gel

Courtesy
$18
SHOP IT

The tiny brush makes it a breeze to apply this waterproof gel, which helps bump up brows to Brooke Shields levels.

8 of 42

EYELINER: Too Faced Better Than Sex Easy Glide Waterproof Liquid

Courtesy
$21
SHOP IT

For wings so perfectly engineered you could almost take flight, try this ultra-precise, glossy onyx pen.

9 of 42

EYE SHADOW: Marc Jacobs Beauty O!mega Gel Powder

Courtesy
$29
SHOP IT

With perennial faves like cocoa brown, sheer gold, and warm berry, these are the shadows you’ll want to wear every day. Good thing the single compacts are jumbo size.

Advertisement
Advertisement
Advertisement

10 of 42

MASCARA: Tarte Big Ego Vegan

Courtesy
$23
SHOP IT

The twisted bristles catch every lash, coating each one with a lengthening pitch-black ink.

11 of 42

NAIL POLISH: Sally Hansen Mega Strength

Courtesy
$6
SHOP IT

Consider a coat of this platinum-infused formula the next-best thing to wearing gloves: It protects nails from breaks, splits, and cracks.

12 of 42

LIQUID LIP PRODUCT: L’Oréal Paris Rouge Signature Matte Liquid Lipstick

Courtesy
$12
SHOP IT

The extended wear and the lightweight feel make this a matte you can commit to comfortably.

Advertisement
Advertisement
Advertisement

13 of 42

EDITOR'S PICK: Charlotte Tilbury Latex Love

Courtesy
$34
SHOP IT

When you want a slick vinyl shine, pick one of these six sexy, limited-edition shades from red-carpet makeup artist Charlotte Tilbury.

14 of 42

LIP GLOSS: Stila Beauty Boss

Courtesy
$15
SHOP IT

It would take several swipes of your standard gloss to achieve the shine you can get with this formula. It’s flecked with light-reflecting pearls for a glistening sheen minus the stickiness.

15 of 42

LIPSTICK: Maybelline New York Made for All by Color Sensational

Courtesy
$8
SHOP IT

You’re sure to find a new signature among the line’s multi-tone neutrals and universal reds.

Advertisement
Advertisement
Advertisement

16 of 42

LIMITED-EDITION LAUNCH: Nars Orgasm Collection

Courtesy
SHOP IT

Featuring shimmering shades of rose, gold, and peach, the face compact and matching lip gloss flatter complexions without coming on too strong.

17 of 42

SERUM: Glow Recipe Pineapple-C Bright

Courtesy
$49
SHOP IT

It brightens with exfoliating acids and enzymes. Pineapple offers a dose of antioxidant vitamin C for cell protection.

18 of 42

ANTI-AGING TREATMENT: No7 Laboratories Line Correcting Booster Serum

Courtesy
$42
SHOP IT

Peptides in the silky serum work to make skin look firmer and perkier.

Advertisement
Advertisement
Advertisement

19 of 42

EYE CREAM: RevitaLash Cosmetics AquaBlur Hydrating Eye Gel & Primer

Courtesy
$65
SHOP IT

Your undereye makeup is less likely to crease and crinkle if you prep with a super-hydrating primer like this.

20 of 42

MOISTURIZER: Tatcha The Dewy Skin Cream

Courtesy
$68
SHOP IT

The gel-like antioxidant cream leaves your face feeling supple and hydrated for hours.

21 of 42

PRIMER: Ole Henriksen Banana Bright

Courtesy
$36
SHOP IT

We love the versatility of this glistening lotion, which helps brighten skin thanks to vitamin C. You can wear it as a makeup primer or mix a bit into your base to get an immediate glow.

Advertisement
Advertisement
Advertisement

22 of 42

EDITOR'S PICK: Neutrogena Rapid Wrinkle Repair Retinol Oil

Courtesy
$25
SHOP IT

For dry-skin types who bristle at the thought of using retinol serums, this winner delivers the potent line-fighting ingredient in a soothing oil.

23 of 42

CLEANSER: Drunk Elephant Slaai Makeup Melting Butter

Courtesy
$34
SHOP IT

We’d never tell you to skip moisturizer, but washing with this marula-oil-spiked balm leaves skin so soft, you could almost get away with it.

24 of 42

ANTI-ACNE TREATMENT: Murad Outsmart Acne Clarifying Treatment

Courtesy
$44
SHOP IT

The pimple fighter targets dead, pore-clogging cells with salicylic acid.

Advertisement
Advertisement
Advertisement

25 of 42

FACE MASK: Milk Makeup Cannabis Hydrating

Courtesy
$24
SHOP IT

Flaky on your forehead but oily everywhere else? This moisturizing mask, containing aloe, glycerin, and cannabis-seed oil, comes in a twist-up stick so you can target areas easily.

26 of 42

FACIAL TREATMENT: Philosophy Renewed Hope in a Jar Peeling Mousse Instant Glow Facial

Courtesy
$35
SHOP IT

For the days when five minutes of alone time feels like an eternity, rub on this exfoliating treatment (with pineapple and witch hazel), which will get you glowing in 60 seconds.

27 of 42

EXFOLIATOR: Peter Thomas Roth Peptide 21 Amino Acid Exfoliating Peel Pads

Courtesy
$52
SHOP IT

One of these pads, packed with salicylic and phytic acids, deposits calming chamomile to help counteract redness

Advertisement
Advertisement
Advertisement

28 of 42

BODY PRODUCT: Merle Norman Cosmetics Anti-Aging Complex Body Lotion

Courtesy
$43
SHOP IT

The skin below your neck needs attention too, and this antioxidant-rich cream brings a tripeptide into the mix to help with deep lines and creases.

29 of 42

SPF: CeraVe Hydrating Sunscreen SPF 30 Face

Courtesy
$18
SHOP IT

It’s quite the people pleaser: This fragrance-free mineral lotion blends in without a fight and leaves no tacky residue.

30 of 42

NATURAL BEAUTY MVP: Herbivore Botanicals Emerald CBD + Adaptogens Deep Moisture Glow Oil

Courtesy
$58
SHOP IT

If your complexion is more reactive than a rejected contestant on The Bachelor, try this soothing blend made with anti-inflammatory ingredients.

Advertisement
Advertisement
Advertisement

31 of 42

BATH PRODUCT: Caress Sheer Twilight Body Wash

Courtesy
$4
SHOP IT

The gel completely soothes the senses with its woodsy scent of black orchid and amber.

32 of 42