"Tonight we channeled a look reminiscent of Cindy Crawford from the 90's, but put a modern twist on it with a glossy orange red lipstick and blowy skin," said makeup artist Mary Phillips of her bold look, which complimented her bright orange Bec & Bridge dress. "We also added an orange shadow to the lids to warm up her eyes."
Want more J. Lo fashion? Visit InStyle.com every Thursday and Friday this season to catch more of Jennifer Lopez’s American Idol style moments, and see all of her head-to-toe looks from Idol by clicking through our gallery!