Cohen asked the multihyphenate three questions and gave her the option of "pleading the Fifth" on only one. For the first question, Cohen asked Lopez to identify which of her American Idol co-stars (Keith Urban, Harry Connick Jr., and Ryan Seacrest) she would choose to marry, shag, or kill. "That is so mean! I've got to kill one of them? I can't, I can't!" Lopez said. "They're very sensitive. I'm the toughest one on the show."
After thinking for a while, she finally said, "I think I would marry Ryan. I ... Oh, I can't do this! You know what, let's bail on this. It's too weird. They're like my brothers! You don't understand."
Next Cohen asked for her honest opinion on her former partner Ben Affleck's giant back tattoo of a phoenix. "It's awful!" she exclaimed with a laugh. "I mean, I would tell him that. Like, c'mon what are you doing? It has too many colors! His tattoos always have too many colors. They shouldn't have so many colors. They should be cooler, I don't know."
Finally, Cohen asked Lopez to describe her relationship with Mariah Carey because she was photographed texting during the "Vision of Love" singer's 2015 Billboard Music Awards performance and didn't catch any of Carey's concerts in Las Vegas last year.
"First of all, that was not fair with the texting thing. I watched a lot of it! It was a long performance," she explained. "I watched most of it. I may have looked down for one second. It's so not fair, I was watching her the whole time."
As for the Vegas show, she said, "I don't think there's been a time where I could have seen it."
Well, that settles it!
Watch JLo's entire game of Plead the Fifth in the above video.