Transformation

Sarah Michelle Gellar is a hair and makeup perfectionist. As a teenaged star, the Buffy the Vampire Slayer lead paired artfully-arranged coifs with precisely-drawn crimson lipstick that somehow never got on her teeth. Now a horror movie icon (the Grudge movies, anyone?), she will be returning to the small screen with a dual role in Ringer that she is sure to execute, well, flawlessly.

Blossom-bedecked hat, dark lipstick—the All My Children actress kept up with '90s trends.