Her look is almost too off-kilter to be that of a star’s. Then why do we keep watching? Because Gyllenhaal repeatedly exudes elegance with unforeseen choices, like this checked, beaded smock and pegged silk wrap pants. On her, it’s so right. On you? Well, why not try it.
At left: Gyllenhaal in Proenza Schouler
Copyright © 2013 Time Inc. InStyle is a registered trademark of Time Inc. All rights reserved.