: Eisdell blended two shades of cream eye shadows along Mulligan's lids: Chanel Illusion D'Ombre in Mirifique, a sparkly slate, and Fantasme, an icy white ($36 each; chanel.com
). A few generous coats of YSL Faux Cils mascara ($30; yslbeautyus.com
) finished lashes. BROWS
: "I sharpened Carey's eyebrows with The Make Up Store Tri Brow Color ($27; makeupstore.se
), extending the shape a bit to add drama," Eisdell tells us. FINISHING TOUCH
: A sweep of Dior Bois De Rosebud ($42; sephora.com
) kept Mulligan from looking too cold.