Got streaks? You can exfoliate too-dark areas to even things out. But if you want to remove the faux glow completely, smooth baby oil over your skin, then exfoliate. "Oil will lift the color fast," explains Gigi Zunjic, owner of Tan2U, a mobile tanning service in Miami. Try Johnson's baby oil ($2; at drugstores).
EcoTools Recycled Bath & Shower gloves, $4; at Target.Read MoreLess