"Anytime she puts that rag on her head, I kind of hold my breath," Rubenstein said. And the Hermes scarf Carrie paired with a pink vintage prom dress is no exception. "This is TV, not fashion," he explained. Weinberg seconded his opinion: "This looks like something Katy Perry would wear to the Grammys," she said. "And those white Manolo pumps were like a Catholic-schoolgirl-gone-bad."