Todd Johnson Photography (tjweddings.com)
Warren sent Reeser on a daylong scavenger hunt around L.A. in 2007, revisiting all their relationship landmarks. "If the day wasn't going where I hopedan engagementI didn't know how he could ever top it," says Reeser. The final stop? A private dinner at the Inn of the Seventh Ray near Mailbu, Calif. where Warren proposed with a vintage 1910 ring from Neil Lane's Archival Collection, featuring a European-cut center stone and surrounding diamonds set in platinum.