March 31st: Scott MacInstyre
Kara DioGuardi called MacIntyre's rendition of Billy Joel's "Just The Way You Are" "a moving performance," and she went on to compliment his new look. "I cut the hair," said MacIntyre, who wore a V-neck Alternative Apparel top, Diesel leather jacket and Rich & Skinny jeans. Simon Cowell called the song his "Best performance by a country mile. It's a different Scott."