Yes, dark shades can exaggerate thin lips, making them look like a flat line. “The darker the color, the smaller your lips will appear, and a matte texture makes lips seem even smaller,” says Bower. But that doesn’t mean that those lacking a voluptuous pout are left out of the trend. Simply “go for more of a soft, stained lip rather than a hard, defined shape you’d get with an opaque lipstick,” says Lee. Or “try using a tinted lip balm” says Bower.
Burt's Bees Lip Shimmer in Plum ($5; drugstore.com)
Clinique Almost Lipstick in Black Honey ($15; clinique.com)
MORE: See our top makeup, hair and skincare picks of 2012 in InStyle's Best Beauty Buys list.Read MoreLess