Forget playgrounds, beauty editors have Sephora. No one loves making a trip to the beauty product mecca quite like InStyle’s beauty team. While our editors are never without a selection of new makeup, skincare, and hair products to try, there’s a few select few that can be found at the retailer—who carries everything from prestige to indie brands—that they simply can’t live without. From sheet masks to highlighters, if you often find yourself overwhelmed when browsing the aisles of beauty heaven, our editors are more than happy to offer a few suggestions. Keep reading for the must-have products our beauty editors pick up during a visit to Sephora.